Tuesday12th March

John Brooks

45 Years In The Business

A long-standing LMS member, John Brooks is well known to music lovers in Leicester as a recordings expert, first in Brees record shop and then his own Classic Tracks. His knowledge of recorded music is vast and he will review the many changes in recorded sound he has seen and dealt in over the years, from 78's through to DVDs.

Appreciation by Alan Herringshaw

It was clear from the outset, if not from the first recorded example, that John's talk would be more than a choice of musical items! The first recording of Sir Arthur Sullivan was a remarkable indication of the human predisposition for invention without a clear idea of what it would eventually lead to and despite its lack of clarity and audio quality it was a clear statement of where John’s talk would lead us!

In his talk John managed to interweave the history of recording technology with a wide ranging selection of John's favourite pieces gleaned from over 40 years serving the city of Leicester with a choice of classical music firstly in Brees Record Store in Churchgate and eventually in Classic Tracks in Bond Street.

As might be inferred from such an immersion in the classical music genre, the choices of music were very well chosen. We were treated to Winifred Atwell playing Grieg’s piano concerto, whose pianistic style was such that the answer to the question posed by John (who do you think is playing here?) was obvious once you knew the answer! This was followed by one of Janáček's typically melodramatic operas…

I remarked in my vote of thanks that there were a number of musical juxtapositions that made the play list wonderfully diverse and eclectic and at the same time extremely entertaining, of which, Winifred Atwell and Káťa Kabanová was the first.

We were treated to the Mikado, the eponymous character from Gilbert and Sullivan’s Mikado trying to make himself heard above a noisy crowd, followed by an excerpt from Britten's War Requiem conducted by the composer himself.

After a brief light classical interlude (Robert Mandell and the Melachrino Strings) and a short interval, the second half of the talk set off on another interesting meander including John’s memories of the great European orchestras of the time playing to packed concert halls both in Leicester and abroad in their home cities. The Berliner Philharmoniker conducted by Herbert von Karajan and the Wienerphilharmoniker (Wagner’s Ring Cycle conducted by Sir Georg Solti) neatly bookended three examples of soloists of similar stature. The world famous soloists, Nigel Kennedy (Spring from Vivaldi’s The Four Seasons), James Galway with a beautifully lyrical flute and piano duet (Francesco Morlacchi, Il Pastore Svizzero) and, of course, somewhere in there were The Three Tenors singing Nessun Dorma from Giacomo Puccini's opera Turandot.

All in all an evening of exceptional musical variety and experiences and a reminder of how the retail business will never be the same again—I have to stop now, my Amazon delivery is at the door…

Playlist

ItemDescriptionLabel
1.Voice of Sir Arthur SullivanPearl Gemm CD 9991
ComposerPieceArtists
2.Elgar Enigma Variations FinalePhilharmonia, BarbirolliEMI CDM 566322 2
3.Grieg Piano ConcertoWinifred Atwell, London Philharmonic, Stanford RobinsonVocalion CDLK 4285
4.Janáček Káťa Kabanová, OvertureCzech Philharmonic, MackerrasSupraphon SU 3739 2 032
5.Sullivan The Mikado’s SongDonald Adams, Welsh National Opera Chorus and OrchestraTelarc CD 80284
6.Britten War Requiem, Dies IraeThe Bach Choir & London Symphony Orchestra, BrittenDecca 414383 2
7.Carmichael StardustRobert Mandell & The Melachrino Strings & OrchestraVocalion CDEA 6020
8.Beethoven Symphony No 6, 3rd movementBerlin Philharmonic, KarajanDeutsche Grammophon 4139322
9.Morlacchi Il Pastore SvizzeraJames Galway flute, Philip Moll pianoBMG 092026 6888 2
10.Vivaldi Four SeasonsNigel Kennedy, Berlin PhilharmonicEMI 7243 5 57648 2
11.Puccini Nessun Dorma (Turandot)3 Tenors: Carreras, Domingo, PavarottiDecca 4304332
12.Wagner Immolation Scene, GötterdämmerungThe Golden Ring: Birgit Nilsson, Vienna Philharmonic, Sir Georg SoltiDecca 455 3364

Images

Marginalia

Which Morlacchi?

John attributed the virtuoso flute piece Il Pastore Svizzero to Francesco Morlacchi (1784–1841). And, indeed, so it says in the track list of the James Galway CD. However, a very interesting post about the piece in online flute magazine The Babel Flute says that this is a misattribution, and that the piece was in fact composed by the apparently unrelated Pietro Morlacchi (1828–1868).

The Golden Ring

If you haven't already seen it, Humphrey Burton's 1964 documentary about the making of Solti's Ring is well worth a look.